Localfund.com - All about Fund and Investment
*Home>>>Investment Account

What it the difference between internal rate of return and interest rate?


When comparing investment in a bank account versus investment in a property (for example), one would like to compare the property investment with the interest rate obtainable from a bank account. When calculating the Internal Rate of Return for a property investment, if one recalculates the same investement amount as if it were in a bank account earning an interest rate equivalent to the IRR, the results are different. Why is that?
Is there a way of generating a percentage rate from IRR which is comparable with other forms of investment?

I was going to say

"IRR is the bank interest rate that you have to beat to make your investment worth the risk"

but then I read on and it looks like you got that far already, further in fact, because it looks like my explanation doesn't hold good.

Another way of looking at it is to say you're going to borrow for your investment at a certain rate. IRR is the borrowing rate at which your project is breakeven in Net Present Value terms - i.e., it generates no returns; the NPV is zero.

I think the problem with the calcs could be one of two things

(1) the way the interest rate is expressed in banking is very important - how often the interest is calculated, where it's paid, is it compounding, etc

(2) MS Excel has (I believe) a bug in the IRR function. It's possible to calculate an IRR, then use that IRR to calculate an NPV, and for that NPV to not be equal to zero - which it should be if the IRR is calculated correctly.

Always do your IRR/NPV calcs explicitly and don't trust Excel. Note, no-one else thinks that, just me. So maybe I'm wrong about that too...

With all this depreciation, what's the NPV of my ten points now?

dunno

IRR is the interest rate applicable only in the instance when NPV(net present value) would equal "zero".

Otherwise, Interest rate can be anything.

Interest rates are usually annualised numbers. Have you done the same with the IRR?

You can calculate IRR & Return rates for both the property as well as the bank account.

1) Calculate the amount of returns you are going to get from each of them seperately. like maybe u get 9%/yr and 6%/yr compunded. on this case, you can see thatu have to choose 9% since it gives higher returns

2) IRR is the rate of inflation at which your present value of investment becomes zero. so if the IRR of the bank investment is 12% and the IRR of the property is 14%, so that means that if inflation goes upto 12%, your bank account will yield no returns while your property investment gives you 2%

there is a possibility that both methods may give you different decisions..you have to decide in that case, wether to go for higher returns with higher risk of inflation or vice versa.

now, USUALLY, banks always cover the inflation rate so u are always covered by the bank in that case...

I would not recommend that you compare alternative investments using IRR. This is because the implied discount rate would be different for each of the investments, which makes no sense. It is better to decide on your personal discount rate, then compare the NPVs of the alternative investments at that rate.

Probably because of compounding in the bank account. In Excel the IRR of cashflows for a 3 year investment like (-1000, 100, 100, 1100) will be 10%. However on a bankaccount calculation the value after 3 year would be 1331. This takes into account interest earned on interest, while the IRR does not do that.

Interest rates generally are IRRs, but not all IRRs are interest rates.

When we talk about interest rates, we usually mean the yields of Treasury Bonds. A yield is the rate that equates the price of a bond with the present value of the future flows. In other words, if you find the present value of each future cash flow -- discounting at the yield, then add them together, it gives you the value of the bond.

An IRR is also an interest rate that gives you the proper price. But IRRs are used for other things as well -- such as finding the return of a corporate project or a loan.

Tags
  Investment Company   Investment Calculator   Investment Bank   Investment Advice   Investment Account   Invest Money   Invest in Gold   Invest Fund   Income Fund
Related information
  • Accounting question about investments?

    My guess would be non-influential and non-controlling, as I interpret this to mean <20% ownership. These investments would be accounted for as "available-for-sale" and recorded at cos...

  • Finance Question regarding investing, APR and EPR?- any help is appreciated?

    OK I don't have my Finance Calculator with me right now (if I remember I will comeback and answer it.) But to figure it out all you need to do is a.) put in FV=$9,500, (I) 6% and (N or time) ...

  • Finance Question regarding investing, APR and EPR?

    If you do your own work you will have a skill that will serve you well over a lifetime. Give it a try, and let us know when you get stuck.

    ...
  • Finances...?

    I would say when you're younger (theoretically have less money) it's easier and a better idea to go all under one roof. This is likely to save you money as well considering you receive a ...

  • Where is a safe place to keep money?

    a safe

    ...
  • Money Laundring???

    DO NOT respond to that email. This is a classic case of ADVANCE FEE FRAUD. Check out this website called www.phonebusters.com for more detail. Think about it, who will give you something in this...

  • How much should your net worth be by your 30s?

    The calc the 1st person told has a slight flaw I think. Most people don't make a ton of money straight out of school. Plus, you also have loans which puts you at a negative net worth startin...

  • What would you recommend financially for a responsible young adult?

    1) Always have the mean to pay off your credit card balance every month (unless its a large purchase, then you should ask the store about 0% financing and spread the cost during those months). Neve...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster