Localfund.com - All about Fund and Investment
*Home>>>Investment Advice

401k / Traditional IRA / ROTH IRA - Will go back to India in 5 years permanently?


I am 30 years old working in California and would like to make some good investment. I will be going back to my home country India for good in next 5 years. In this case does using 401k/Traditional IRA/Roth IRA help? Each of these seems to allow taking money only after 60years. If I take before that I will end up paying tax and also penalty. I would like to take most of my money when I go back in 5 years. My company has 401k plan but they do not match my contributions. Please advice..

How about about several short and long term CD's (certificates of deposit) with banks that pay the most?

YOUR COMPANY SUCKS! YOU WILL GO BACK BROKE!

These investment vehicles are certainly not for you. I'd highly recommending investing your money in an index fund, for multiple reason which I won't go in to, but will source below.

Best of luck.

You may want to read more in the tax deffered investment and you can do the fund management yourselfd such as " Self Direct IRA " or there were many other options that you need to explore!

Then five years from now, you can freely draw and reinvest when, where, what, why and how yourlself and you even can decide what to make profit once you are good at what you doing.

Keep in mind follow the rule strickly, but learn to use the rule to work to your advantage, then you would have much save investement and happy long prosperity life.

I help people, becasue people help me before. Let hear more!

The short answer is no you don't want to use one of these tax deferred savings plans if you plan to take out the money in 5 years. If you put money into a 401k - typically you will "break even" with a similiar investment out side of a 401k (ie same mutual fund for example).in about 7-8 years. So if you said you plan to return to India in 15 years - then a 401k etc would make sense even after paying the penalty for early withdrawal. This is even more true since your company does not provide a 401k match.

Based on the information you provided, it is probably NOT a prudent idea to invest your money in a 401k plan (especially while not getting any company match money).

Since you signaled that you will be withdrawing the money in about 5 years (still putting you well under 59.5 years of age) you are going to be penalized 10% on the money you take out. Also, you are going to add all of that money to your income for that 5th year and will probably push yourself into a higher marginal tax bracket. It is most likely better for you to spread out the taxes over the 5 years (it ultimately depends on how much you plan on saving each year) than to take that one lump sum hit.

The penalty itself can end up ruining any gains you have from tax-deferrment now anyway.

401k plans are used to save for retirement, and your situation doesn't mention anything about you wanting to save for retirement. You just want to obtain some monetary gains on discretionary income you're going to come across in the next 5 years.

If you want to invest in the stock market, just open up a NON-Retirement brokerage account at any major financial institution or local bank. Local banks should give you better deals on annual fees/commissions if you're not planning on saving too much (let's just pick an arbitrary figure and say under $100k over that 5 year term).

Good luck.

-Sean

Tags
  Investment Firms   Investment Company   Investment Calculator   Investment Bank   Investment Advice   Investment Account   Invest Money   Invest in Gold   Invest Fund
Related information
  • Obtaining a Graduate Actuarial Job in the US as a British Citizen?

    The only advice I can offer is offered as the mother of an actuary who has been working in the field since he graduated from college about a year and a half ago. He majored in Actuarial Science ...

  • Whats a good way to start investing in the stock market?

    Great Moves! I think these articles will help: How to Find Good Stocks That Will Survive 2008 Market Crash ...

  • Should I buy house of flat?

    It basically depends on what is right for your personal circumstances. If you are a couple and are planning to have children, then you'll want a garden etc and hence would need a house. A ...

  • Should I buy a home now or wait for the market to slow a little more?

    I believe the best time is now. You may loss some equity, but in time (4-8years) the market will be much better. Yes, it is the best investment a couple can do.

    ...
  • Would traditional IRA be better?

    Personally I would go with the Roth. If you're going to max it out either way, the Roth will be better for you in the long run. Say you max out your IRA for the next 20 or 30 years and end u...

  • New baby on the way and no money?

    of course when the bad guys rob a bank in hollywood movies and say they have no money they are talking about relative povery and also relative to other countries.of course your husband is correct t...

  • If the Inland Revenue have NOT sent you a tax return, even though they know your address etc should I go?

    It's always a good idea to keep records current with the lovely folk at HM Revenue & Customs -- not least to make sure they know you're not earning. Give them a call (the folk on the ...

  • Sold House in Canada, US resident?

    This is a question that the good folks at CRA would be happy to answer. For a quick overview, see the CRA website: Selling or disposing of certain property (link below). After that, a telephone cal...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster