Localfund.com - All about Fund and Investment
*Home>>>Investment Advice

Economics question?


this is the part from my text book.
1984; The supreme Court ruled that as long as a bank does not offer investment advice, it can provide discount brokerage services. Subsequently, appeals courts have ruled that a bank subsidiary can offer advice.

why couldn't the banks offer investment advice? could you please tell me why? what problems would be caused if the banks can offer advice?

Simple answer: conflict of interest. Banks do not make as much money by loaning out money as you would think. Most of their income is derived from investing. As a fellow, and possibly, competitive investor, they could help themselves by encouraging or discouraging certain funds or stocks that they themselves are interested in.
One hypothetical for example: They want to invest in Do-dad stock. It currently sells for $2 a share. The president announces to all the "advisers" to push that stock on March 15. At 5:45 p.m. EST (15 minutes before closing), the bank buys 1,000,000 shares for $2,000,000. The next day, because of the advice of all the "advisers," another 1,000,000 shares are bought up throughout the day and the price rises to $2.10/share. That doesn't seem like much to the guy that bought 10 shares and only sees a profit of $1 (10 x $.10) but the bank is (literally) making bank. In one day, they made $100,000 (1,000,000 x $.10).
The idea behind the rule was to remove the temptation that banks could have to benefit themselves. If you look at the study of economics as not being the study of money but as the study of what makes people make the choices they make, then this seems like a wise rule.
I wonder why they took it away and how many banks decided to use this to their own advantage.

banks and brokerages used to be the same business. they were divided after the great Depression started to prevent abuses that had occurred. [depositors' money had been used to fund bonds and stocks held for sale to investors, even after it became clear that investors weren't going to buy the securities.]

i think this was part of the Securities and Exchange Act of 1933 and maybe I'm in error about that.

Tags
  Investment Firms   Investment Company   Investment Calculator   Investment Bank   Investment Advice   Investment Account   Invest Money   Invest in Gold   Invest Fund
Related information
  • As a first time home buyer, what is your advice for me in this current housing market?

    I won't be harsh, but I WILL be realistic. If ANY of us had access to that real estate crystal ball, we would not be sitting here answering these questions. Your guess is as good as mine, ...

  • Is it a good idea to continue to make automatic payments to my investment funds during this down market?

    If you've lost 60% of what you put into the market last month, I think you need to reevaluate WHAT you're investing in. It's not the market itself that is losing you money. What yo...

  • Where can I find manual and technical support for formation of investment clubs in Nigeria?

    ...

  • Opinions of Fool.com?

    The Fool has excellent and solid investment advice. I have been following them since they began and over all their record is impressive. They can make you a well informed investor.

    ...
  • How do i turn $500 into $5000?

    You can do forex trading. Get more details at - ...

  • Series 65 license priviledges & restrictions?

    The series 65 and 66 is for the RIA. RIA's are held to a higher fiduciary requirement pertaining to advice, than stockbrokers whose "advise" is only incidental to their business. Fur...

  • Best way to save $4k-$5k over 2 years?

    The very best way that I know of is if you get paid 2 times a month as many people do, then you want to set aside $100 every pay check. It is that simple.

    ...
  • Is eBay fundementally overvalued?

    I was on the same page with you but, with their recent work with Google I feel they are still a market leader and they do have room to grow. Though i keep them within my speculatory stock folder, s...

  •  

    Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster